Skip to content
Home » Articles » Make Up » The 7 Best Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes in 2022 [Buying Guide]

The 7 Best Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes in 2022 [Buying Guide]

    The 7 Best Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes in 2021 [Buying Guide]

    Adding eyeliner to your makeup instantly amplifies its glam factor. Eyeliner selection is influenced by a number of factors.

    If it doesn’t meet requirements like waterproof, long-lasting and easy application, it may not appeal to some people.

    You might already be aware of how hard it is to find an eyeliner that will not irritate the eyes if you have sensitive skin, wear contact lenses, or suffer from allergies.

    Taking care of your eyelids and the products you choose to use on them is extremely important, as the skin in that region can be extremely sensitive.

    Many experts recommend only using hypoallergenic eye makeup for sensitive skin types. We explain what this beauty jargon really means below.

    Thankfully, there are many fantastic eyeliners to choose from, and some we just love. An in-depth look at the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes along with our reasons for selecting each pick is presented in this article.

    Patch Test Before Using Any New Skin Product

    The skin surrounding the eyes is thin and delicate, making it specifically sensitive. A substance that we are allergic to causes our body to create antibodies to attack it.

    In response to the allergen, mast cells are activated in the body. The eyes and nose also contain mast cells, as do the lungs, stomach, and intestines. 

    A hand-test before applying new makeup can make a huge difference. Before you put it on your eyes, you should wait an hour or two to see if it has a reaction on your hand or forearm.

    (Please consult a licensed medical professional before applying a new cosmetic, eyeliner, lipstick, or any skincare product if you’re worried about its side effects. A personal doctor or a dermatologist would be a good choice. This article should be used only for “informational purposes”.)

    Makeup Tips for Sensitive Eyes

    Lining the inner eye is not a good idea

    Those with sensitive eyes need to be extra cautious when lining their inner eyes. Line the outer lash line with a pencil or a liner. 

    Always remove makeup before going to bed

    Makeup removal is not easy, many women will agree to this. After a long day, the last thing you want to do is remove your makeup!

    Using eye cream in moderation

    Apply eye cream by gently patting it outside the corner of your eyes to the inside.

    Also Read: How To Remove Waterproof Mascara

    How to choose Best Eyeliner For Sensitive Eyes (Buying Guide)


    First, you should decide what color eyeliner you want. Maybe you’re looking for a neutral shade to wear every day.

    The best way to choose the right color for your eyeshadow is to select something that complements your natural eye colour.


    Eyeliners come in different types. Sharp, thin lines are achieved by liquid eyeliner. Conversely, felt-tip eyeliner creates thicker yet softer lines.

    Pencil eyeliner can be used to make either thin or thick and sharp and soft lines, depending on the pencil. This is why you should choose eyeliner that will help you achieve your desired results.


    You don’t have to worry about waterproof eyeliners smudging or flaking. Whether you live in a dry or humid environment, these eyeliners are perfect for you.

    In addition, they’re a good choice for someone wearing contacts or someone whose eyes tend to become watery.

    Return policy

    Sometimes, you may purchase a product only to discover it does not work for you. Depending on the store, you may be able to return an item whether you opened it and used it or not.

    It is not easy to return other goods once opened and used. Before buying, familiarize yourself with the return policy.

    Hand steadiness

    Choosing the best eyeliner begins with making sure you have steady hands. It may be more convenient to choose a pencil eyeliner if you have unsteady hands or are new to wearing eyeliner. They are the easiest to use. 

    For people who are advanced in the eyeliner game, have steady hands and have application skills, liquid eyeliners are the best choice.

    Beware of Certain Ingredients

    Those with sensitive skin and eyes should avoid eyeliners with certain ingredients. Listed below are some common triggers that might cause allergic reactions.

    • Alcohol

    The fact that alcohol is a great preservative for makeup makes it a common ingredient in many cosmetics. Additionally, it kills bacteria and it also has the effect of tightening pores.

    Unfortunately, it can have an irritating or drying effect on the eyes, making it unsuitable for those with sensitive skin.

    • Chemicals

    The use of many harmful chemical ingredients in makeup has gained more attention over the last few years, which includes parabens, sulfates, BHAs, and many more.

    Many companies are now removing these chemicals from their products because research indicates they can lead to health problems.

    These chemicals are present in a wide range of cosmetics that is why many companies are doing away with them. 

    However, it is not yet proven but if you have sensitive skin but for those with sensitive skin, it can be sensible to avoid them.

    • Scent

    Those with sensitive skin and eyes should be aware of this common allergen, and try to keep away from it.

    There are chemicals used by companies to make their products smell good but can severely damage the skin. Many makeup enthusiasts who have had reactions on the skin have claimed for the fragrance to be the culprit.

    Fortunately, you can find fragrance-free cosmetics from a variety of great and affordable cosmetics brands.

    7 Best Eyeliners For Sensitive Eyes

    1. Clinique Quick Intense Eye Liner

    Clinique Quick Intense Eye Liner - Dungaree Hungry

    You can easily achieve an intense smokey eye look with Clinique Quick Intense Eye Liner or make your eyes look however you want. Smooth and silky, it glides on easily.

    You can build up the intensity of the eyeliner to make it as dark or as light as you like. It doesn’t need to be sharpened! Besides the sponge, it includes a brush tip with which you can achieve a smokey eye effect.

    With its easy-to-use tip, it can draw precise lines effortlessly. The eyeliner is gentle on the skin, which is ideal for those with sensitive eyes and those who wear contact lenses.

    Key Features:

    • Easy and smooth application
    • Mild on the skin
    • Ideal for sensitive eyes ad contact lens wearers
    • Long-lasting

    2. INIKA Organic Coco Eye Pencil

    INIKA Organic Coco Eye Pencil - Dungaree Hungry

    This pencil liner is vegan and all-natural which means it is safe for sensitive eyes. It is made using non-toxic ingredients and when applied, it is smooth and offers deep shades of color that create natural-looking color.

    Ingredients come from the purest sources in the world and are cruelty-free. There is no other natural liner with a rich consistency like this one.

    3. Neutrogena Intense Gel EyelinerNeutrogena Intense Gel Eyeliner - Dungaree Hungry

    The Neutrogena Intense Gel Eyeliner will give you smudged-out smokey eyes every time. During the first 30 seconds of application, the creamy formula is easy to blend before it dries to a water-resistant finish.

    It’s formulated with vitamin E to keep skin soft, and it’s so gentle, the company claims that you can use it along your waterline.

    It features high pigmentation for lashes that stay in place without cracking or melting. You can use this eyeliner to make your eyes look larger and more vibrant and it will add more value to your beauty regimen.

    4. Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner

    Stila Smudge Stick Waterproof Eyeliner - Best Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes

    This Stila eyeliner is nothing short of amazing. 

    The eyeliner is available in eight different shades, so women who struggle to find a color that matches their skin can try this product. You can draw the perfect wing with its tip, which is smudge-proof.

    Contact lens wearers will appreciate the rich pigmentation of this pencil liner. Known for great pigmentation, Stila’s eyeliners will never dry out your eyes or make them feel uncomfortable.

    The waterproof nature of the eyeliner also means that it will not fade in humid conditions.

    5. Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner

    Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner - Best Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes

    Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner is one of the best waterproof eyeliners for sensitive eyelids. The waterproof eyeliner is smudge-proof and gives you easy control of the intensity of your eyeliner, from thin and discreet to thick and dramatic. 

    It is surprising how easy it is to remove for waterproof eyeliner and it usually lasts all day. Water, mild cleanser, and a cotton ball are all that’s needed to remove it. There will be no skin irritation or inflammation after you remove the eyeliner.

    Maybelline Unstoppable Eyeliner has just one notable shortcoming, It has a very small size compared to most other options. If you use it frequently, the product may only last a month.

    Even so, it is one of the best eyeliners for sensitive eyes to buy in 2021.

    6. Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash

    Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash - Best Eyeliners for Sensitive Eyes

    While the Physicians Formula Eye Booster Lash may look like your regular liquid liner, it actually helps define and condition your lashes, too.

    The Japanese formula used in this makes the liner perfect for enhancing your lashes and lining your eyes however you want.

    In addition to being long-lasting, waterproof, and smudge-proof, it’s hypoallergenic and fragrance-free. It’s perfect for winged eyeliner looks and stays on all day.

    7. L’Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner

    L'Oreal Paris Infallible Lacquer Eyeliner - Dungaree Hungry

    For a simple yet sophisticated eye makeup look, this infallible lacquer eyeliner from L’Oreal Paris is perfect. The brush glides smoothly, which reduces the likelihood of mistakes during application.

    It’s designed specifically for people who wear contact lenses or have sensitive eyes. This gel liner gives a perfect bold shade, don’t clump and apply easily. With the ability to last for long, it is ideal for everyday use. 

    You can blend the color perfectly with this liner’s perfect flat brush. This product comes in a variety of attractive shades, including black, dark blue, grey and brown. Any makeup remover will easily remove this product.

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *